Good Food - Good Spirits - Good Friends
(860) 388-9646

Great Beginnings

$11.99 Spinach & Artichoke Dip

PLP’s signature blend of cheeses with baby spinach and artichoke hearts finished with chopped tomatoes and served with corn tortilla chips


$12.99 Penny Lane Nachos

Tortilla chips with tomatoes, red onions, black olives, jalapeños & cheese. Sides of sour cream, salsa & chili.


$6.99 Bond Street Onion Rings with Chipotle


$10.99 Piccadilly Wings – Buffalo Style


$13.99 Prince Edward Island Mussels (gf)

With chorizo in a saffron vegetable ragout


$13.99 Prince Phillip’s Crab Cake

Two pan fried crab cakes on a bed of greens with two sauces: dill-tomato aioli and mango wasabi coulis


$11.99 Calamari with Cherry Peppers

Tossed with mild southern seasonings, cherry peppers and fresh basil aioli


$11.99 Chicken Quesadilla

With tomatoes, red onions, black olives, jalapeños & cheese. Side of sour cream and salsa.


$13.99 Coconut Shrimp

Four coconut encrusted jumbo shrimp, orange-horseradish sauce



Sensational Salads

Add one of the following to any salad: Grilled Chicken +4.99     Grilled Salmon +8.99    Crab Cakes +9.99    Grilled Shrimp +9.99

$7.99 Pub Salad (gf)


$8.99 Classic Caesar Salad


$11.99 The Abbey’s Poached Pear Salad (gf)

Pears poached in port wine, mixed greens, caramelized pecans, cranberries and crumbled Gorgonzola cheese tossed with a light orange black raspberry dressing.


$14.99 Chilmark Chopped Cobb Salad (gf)

Chopped chicken, cheddar cheese, egg, avocado, tomato, and applewood bacon over chopped romaine


$16.99 Grilled Sirloin and Arugula Salad

Potato frites, gorgonzola, pears, cherry tomatoes, white balsamic and honey dressing


House-Made Dressings

Dijon-Balsamic Vinaigrette Caesar Bleu Cheese Honey Mustard Thousand Island Parmesan Peppercorn Roquefort and Walnuts (+1.50) Balsamic Vinegar & Olive Oil


$17.99 Jerk and Orange Glazed Shrimp (gf)

A warm salad of roasted butternut squash, cranberries, brussels sprouts, red onions and goat cheese, white balsamic dressing



Children's Menu

12 years old and under

$7.99 Hot Dog


$7.99 Grilled Cheese


$7.99 Hamburger/Cheeseburger


$7.99 Macaroni & Cheese


$7.99 Chicken Tenders


$3.95 Kid’s Hot Fudge Sundae



Savory Soups

Cup: $4.99 Bowl: $5.99 New England Clam Chowder


Cup: $4.59 Bowl: $5.59 Pub Chili (gf)

Chopped sirloin, red beans & bell peppers. Add sour cream and shredded cheddar cheese +1.50


$6.99 French Onion Soup



Endearing Dinner Entrees

Endearing dinner entrées are served with a house salad

$23.99 Montreal Hanger Steak (gf)

Certified angus beef, grilled and sliced with port wine glaze. Served with mashed potatoes and sautéed baby spinach.


Full Rack $24.99 Half Rack $16.50 Hickory Smoked BBQ Baby Back Ribs

Served with pub fries.


$24.99 Grilled New York Strip Steak

Certified Angus Beef, fresh herb and shallot butter, mashed potatoes & green beans


$22.99 Seared Salmon Filet (gf)

Roasted jalapeno vinaigrette, brussels sprouts, sweet potatoes, roasted butternut squash puree


$17.99 Corned Beef and Cabbage (Thursday Only, 5:00pm)

Thursday after 5:00 pm and St. Patrick's Day Week.


Market Price Black Angus Prime Rib of Beef au Jus (Fri.&Sat. after 5:00pm)

With Yorkshire pudding, mashed potatoes and green beans


$19.99 Polenta and Grilled Vegetable Melt (gf)

Grilled polenta cake topped with squash, roasted bell peppers, onions, portobello mushrooms, tomatoes and cheddar cheese, finished with a balsamic glaze.


$17.99 Fish and Chips

Freshly breaded and deep fried domestic cod with pub fries, cole slaw tartar sauce and a side salad.


$17.99 Shepherd’s Pie (gf)

Ground sirloin layered with sweet corn, carrots and onion then baked with a mashed potato crust.


$20.99 Lord Saye’s Liver & Onions

Calves liver sautéed with caramelized onions and applewood bacon. Served with mashed potatoes and green beans.


$19.99 Newcastle Free Range Roasted Chicken (gf)

Half chicken, roasted garlic lemon sauce, smashed cauliflower and julienne vegetables


$23.99 Seafood Fettuccini

Shrimp, calamari and mussels in a roasted tomato-saffron-vegetable "bolognese" tossed with chorizo and fettuccini


$18.99 Mum’s Meatloaf

Served with mashed potatoes and green beans



Between the Breads

Served with your choice of pub fries, chips or cole slaw. Add $2.59 to substitute sweet potato fries or onion rings.  Gluten Free Rolls Available Upon Request +$1.50

$11.99 Corned Beef Reuben

Corned beef, Swiss cheese, sauerkraut & Thousand Island dressing on marble rye.


$11.99 Grilled Chicken Sandwich

Marinated chicken breast with lettuce, tomato on a brioche roll, side of chipotle mayonnaise


$13.99 Liverpool Turkey Pub Club

Roasted turkey and applewood bacon with lettuce, tomato, and mayonnaise on toasted sourdough bread.


$11.99 PLP Burger

Half pound of our own special blend of certified angus ground beef, char grilled to order. Served with lettuce and tomato on a brioche roll. Your choice of pub fries, chips or cole slaw.


$14.99 Bison Burger

One-half pound Canadian bison burger, smoked mozzarella, jalapeño bacon & grilled onions.


$13.59 Salmon Burger

House-made salmon burger with pickled onions lettuce, tomato and tomato aioli.


$11.99 Turkey Burger

With portobello mushrooms, roasted peppers, cheddar cheese, shredded lettuce, basil and cherry pepper aioli


$12.99 Duke’s BBQ Pulled Pork Sandwich

Hickory smoked pork shredded, with grilled onions on a toasted roll with sweet potato fries


$11.99 Southwest Spicy Black Bean Burger

Topped with avocado, served on a brioche roll with a side of chipotle mayo


+ $1.00 Choice of Cheese

American, Cheddar, Gorgonzola, Smoked Mozzarella, Swiss


+ $1.00 Additional Toppings

Grilled Onions, Mushrooms, Cheese, Roasted Bell Peppers


+ $1.50 Additional Toppings

Applewood Bacon, Jalapeño Bacon, Sliced Avocado



Side Dishes

$4.99 Pub Fries


$6.99 Onion Rings


$3.99 Side Vegetable


$6.99 Sweet Potato Fries


$3.99 Smashed Cauliflower


$2.99 PLP House Cole Slaw



Side Substitutions

For an additional charge, side dishes may be substituted

+ $2.59 Onion Rings


+ $2.59 Sweet Potato Fries


+ $2.50 Smashed Cauliflower


+ $1.00 Sub Pub Salad with Caesar Salad


No Charge Cole Slaw